Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
+6
Sean Mirrsen
Armok
MC Dirty
Zangi
Dsarker
Slag
10 posters
Ponies :: Cloudsdale :: Cloudsdale :: Fanfics
Page 4 of 4
Page 4 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Just as I expected. Never heard of the band or the song. Pretty sure we don't get that channel (Is it Discovery Channel? The tags seem to imply that.) either.
MC Dirty- Magical Overlord Unicorn
- Posts : 671
Pony Pals : 5239
Friendship Lessons : 0
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 33
Location : Germany
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Well, whether you heard of it before or not, you have heard it now - so do you think the lyrics I made can be made better? Also, this probably doesn't belong here anymore (it didn't belong here from the start, but it kinda tied into the whole "to be an alien" thing), so maybe I should move it someplace?
Also, you don't have Discovery Channel?
Also, you don't have Discovery Channel?
Sean Mirrsen- Magical Overlord Unicorn
- Posts : 644
Pony Pals : 5178
Friendship Lessons : -7
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 38
Location : Tolyatti, Russia
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Discovery channel? What's that?
Dsarker- BANNED
- Posts : 542
Pony Pals : 5499
Friendship Lessons : -9
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 31
Pony Profile
Name: Dsarker
Spells:
Experience:
(99999/100000)
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Just out of curiosity, when are you going to add that facehoof smiley?
Because,
Alternatively,
And a few more:
Because,
Alternatively,
And a few more:
Sean Mirrsen- Magical Overlord Unicorn
- Posts : 644
Pony Pals : 5178
Friendship Lessons : -7
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 38
Location : Tolyatti, Russia
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Ah, I really enjoyed the most recent part.
The way you handled the scene with Rainbow Dash was very good, I think. I also liked the dialogue with Rarity. It just fits so well since she's probably a huge romantic even after the Blueblood incident. Also, are you really that dextrous? I am pretty ham-handed, so I'm not sure, but Alex seemed to be a bit too good at what he's doing. Then again, you might be really good with your hands, so this is not really a complaint, just something I noticed.
What struck me as odd was how Alex seems to leave the scenes in the oddest moments, mainly in the middle of a conversation. It always seems to me like there's still a lot to talk about, but Alex is like "Yeah, I guess, kthxbye." Then again, that might be how you act in real life. I would probably just keep talking and talking. ^^
I noticed only one error, a jumbled sentence, and that's something that Rarity says near the end of the scene in the kitchen.
The way you handled the scene with Rainbow Dash was very good, I think. I also liked the dialogue with Rarity. It just fits so well since she's probably a huge romantic even after the Blueblood incident. Also, are you really that dextrous? I am pretty ham-handed, so I'm not sure, but Alex seemed to be a bit too good at what he's doing. Then again, you might be really good with your hands, so this is not really a complaint, just something I noticed.
What struck me as odd was how Alex seems to leave the scenes in the oddest moments, mainly in the middle of a conversation. It always seems to me like there's still a lot to talk about, but Alex is like "Yeah, I guess, kthxbye." Then again, that might be how you act in real life. I would probably just keep talking and talking. ^^
I noticed only one error, a jumbled sentence, and that's something that Rarity says near the end of the scene in the kitchen.
I think it's supposed to be "I'll make sure to tell you[...]".Slag wrote:“I’ll make tell you if I ever need help again.”
MC Dirty- Magical Overlord Unicorn
- Posts : 671
Pony Pals : 5239
Friendship Lessons : 0
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 33
Location : Germany
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
I'm not one to talk a lot. Unless I'm invested in the conversation for some reason, I usually leave once I've heard what I want.
As for being dextrous, I'm not the most able-handed, but I have small fingers and a really good eye, so I can pull some pretty dextrous feats. It's not really that hard to pack boxes, anyway. Sewing's a little tougher, but easy enough once you learn how not to prick yourself.
And thanks for finding that. It's fixed.
As for being dextrous, I'm not the most able-handed, but I have small fingers and a really good eye, so I can pull some pretty dextrous feats. It's not really that hard to pack boxes, anyway. Sewing's a little tougher, but easy enough once you learn how not to prick yourself.
And thanks for finding that. It's fixed.
Slag- Delusional Alicorn
- Posts : 1364
Pony Pals : 6653
Friendship Lessons : 8
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 30
Location : America
Pony Profile
Name: Cherry Pop
Spells:
Experience:
(69/99)
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
More stuff done.
Forum needs to be marked 'new' if the last post is edited.
I'm completely self-conscious about my writing and I don't know if it will be any good, so feel free to yell at me using any method you please.
Forum needs to be marked 'new' if the last post is edited.
I'm completely self-conscious about my writing and I don't know if it will be any good, so feel free to yell at me using any method you please.
Slag- Delusional Alicorn
- Posts : 1364
Pony Pals : 6653
Friendship Lessons : 8
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 30
Location : America
Pony Profile
Name: Cherry Pop
Spells:
Experience:
(69/99)
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Well, it's over. Sort of. It's probably not the best ending, but it's what I came up with. If you have any suggestions for improvements or just want to scream obscenities at me for completely screwing up everything, you can do it here or you can comment on the doc itself.
Slag- Delusional Alicorn
- Posts : 1364
Pony Pals : 6653
Friendship Lessons : 8
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 30
Location : America
Pony Profile
Name: Cherry Pop
Spells:
Experience:
(69/99)
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Now that it's finished, I don't have to be super-critical all the time. This pleases me greatly!
I absolutely loved that story! And the ending! I'm glad you didn't pull the "and then, he went back to his own world and was sad." which is how most Humans In Equestria stories generally end. Honestly, I find nothing to criticize about the ending. And I don't even have a vague feeling that there's something wrong with it or something. I genuinely loved it.
Oh, just one thing, you missed a quotation mark.
I absolutely loved that story! And the ending! I'm glad you didn't pull the "and then, he went back to his own world and was sad." which is how most Humans In Equestria stories generally end. Honestly, I find nothing to criticize about the ending. And I don't even have a vague feeling that there's something wrong with it or something. I genuinely loved it.
Oh, just one thing, you missed a quotation mark.
To Be An Alien wrote:She looked at the group. We’ve got to think of something.”
MC Dirty- Magical Overlord Unicorn
- Posts : 671
Pony Pals : 5239
Friendship Lessons : 0
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 33
Location : Germany
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Well, that's good news. Glad you enjoyed it.
I'm kinda surprised that you're pretty much the only person who's been regularly reading it for the last few days, though. Of course, the entire forum hasn't seen too much activity, so I guess nobody's really on much.
I'm kinda surprised that you're pretty much the only person who's been regularly reading it for the last few days, though. Of course, the entire forum hasn't seen too much activity, so I guess nobody's really on much.
Slag- Delusional Alicorn
- Posts : 1364
Pony Pals : 6653
Friendship Lessons : 8
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 30
Location : America
Pony Profile
Name: Cherry Pop
Spells:
Experience:
(69/99)
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Well, I read pretty much everything pony-related that's been produced by Bay12-forumites (except gorn and really long stories). Gotta archive and tag all that stuff, after all.Slag wrote:Well, that's good news. Glad you enjoyed it.
I'm kinda surprised that you're pretty much the only person who's been regularly reading it for the last few days, though. Of course, the entire forum hasn't seen too much activity, so I guess nobody's really on much.
That reminds me, I should probably get to splitting up 18+ and normal stuff now.
MC Dirty- Magical Overlord Unicorn
- Posts : 671
Pony Pals : 5239
Friendship Lessons : 0
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 33
Location : Germany
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
*waves*
You did a great job, Slag. There's a very large bias against self-inserts due to rampant Sue-ism, and relationships with the mane cast even more so, but you handled it well. A thoroughly enjoyable read, for sure :D
You did a great job, Slag. There's a very large bias against self-inserts due to rampant Sue-ism, and relationships with the mane cast even more so, but you handled it well. A thoroughly enjoyable read, for sure :D
Debesh- Oppressed Proletarian Earth Pony
- Posts : 161
Pony Pals : 4751
Friendship Lessons : 12
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 29
Location : United States
Pony Profile
Name: Debesh Unnos
Spells:
Experience:
(11/15)
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
This was actual pretty sweet!
Armok- Second-Class Citizen Pegasus
- Posts : 326
Pony Pals : 4926
Friendship Lessons : 0
Join date : 2011-11-19
Pony Profile
Name:
Spells:
Experience:
(10/10)
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Wll, I've put ABP up on FiMFiction. Seems to be liked, considering it's got a 4.5 rating already.
Slag- Delusional Alicorn
- Posts : 1364
Pony Pals : 6653
Friendship Lessons : 8
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 30
Location : America
Pony Profile
Name: Cherry Pop
Spells:
Experience:
(69/99)
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
I think the rather random and abrupt (not to mention slightly done-to-death) ending will hurt the fic's rating in the long run. And it'll probably raise a few eyebrows over on EqD as well. A little too silly. Well, silly is not a bad thing in and of itself, but the whole "and then X was an Y" is probably too memetic by now to be usable. Consider altering it a little? All I can think of at the moment is "and he lived happily ever after" though, so feel free to disregard my advice.
Sean Mirrsen- Magical Overlord Unicorn
- Posts : 644
Pony Pals : 5178
Friendship Lessons : -7
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 38
Location : Tolyatti, Russia
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
But hey, it didn't become a suefic, unlike practically every self insert ever written.
Flying Dice- Badmin
- Posts : 1757
Pony Pals : 6833
Friendship Lessons : 2
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 31
Location : Somewhere, surrounded by meth labs.
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
I've improved the ending a bit and uploaded To Be An Alien as a second chapter.
Slag- Delusional Alicorn
- Posts : 1364
Pony Pals : 6653
Friendship Lessons : 8
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 30
Location : America
Pony Profile
Name: Cherry Pop
Spells:
Experience:
(69/99)
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
Yeah, that's much better. I'll give it a thorough proofread for typos as soon as I carve out some time for it. Personally, I think this is the best thing you've written so far. Of the things I've seen, at least.
Sean Mirrsen- Magical Overlord Unicorn
- Posts : 644
Pony Pals : 5178
Friendship Lessons : -7
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 38
Location : Tolyatti, Russia
Re: Abducted By Ponies + To Be An Alien (aka Holy Crap It's Not Grimdark)
It's probably the best thing I've written so far that wasn't an essay, that's certain.
Slag- Delusional Alicorn
- Posts : 1364
Pony Pals : 6653
Friendship Lessons : 8
Join date : 2011-11-19
Age : 30
Location : America
Pony Profile
Name: Cherry Pop
Spells:
Experience:
(69/99)
Page 4 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Similar topics
» Ponies Make War/The Immortal Game [Grimdark]
» Sunset: [Grimdark][Sad] / For Want of a Dawn: [Grimdark-War][Adventure]
» Fallout: Equestria[Grimdark][Crossover][Adventure]
» Some Douches Word Dumping Grounds [Rated G for Grimdark]
» Nobody's ponies
» Sunset: [Grimdark][Sad] / For Want of a Dawn: [Grimdark-War][Adventure]
» Fallout: Equestria[Grimdark][Crossover][Adventure]
» Some Douches Word Dumping Grounds [Rated G for Grimdark]
» Nobody's ponies
Ponies :: Cloudsdale :: Cloudsdale :: Fanfics
Page 4 of 4
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum